The Zune Was Better Than We Gave It Credit For

Speaker: 00:00:00

Before we start today's episode, I just want to give a quick shout out to Martin Quibell over in the UK.

Speaker: 00:00:06

Martin is the host of Pods Like Us and the curator of the Podbites newsletter.

Speaker: 00:00:11

Podbites is a curated newsletter of the podcasts that Martin's listening to,

Speaker: 00:00:15

and he's been super supportive of the Artifacts podcast over the last few months,

Speaker: 00:00:18

so I really appreciate that, Martin.

Speaker: 00:00:21

If you want to check out the newsletter or Martin's own podcast,

Speaker: 00:00:24

I'll leave links to that in the episode's show notes, so be sure to check them out.

Speaker: 00:00:28

And now today's episode. If you were buying a portable music player in the mid-2000s,

Speaker: 00:00:34

there was a pretty obvious choice.

Speaker: 00:00:36

You bought an iPod, white earbuds, that little click wheel, and thousands of songs in your pocket.

Speaker: 00:00:42

Apple had managed to turn a music player into something people really wanted

Speaker: 00:00:45

to be seen carrying. And then Microsoft showed up with the Zune.

Speaker: 00:00:50

It was bigger, chunkier, and also available on a share of brown that seemed

Speaker: 00:00:54

designed to start arguments.

Speaker: 00:00:56

It had a name that sounded like somebody had lost a bet in a marketing meeting,

Speaker: 00:00:59

and it was going up against one of the most successful consumer gadgets of the decade.

Speaker: 00:01:04

The Zune became shorthand for a product that couldn't compete with the iPod.

Speaker: 00:01:08

But that reputation misses something. Microsoft wasn't simply trying to build another music player.

Speaker: 00:01:13

It was trying to change the way people discovered and shared music and some

Speaker: 00:01:17

of those ideas were more interesting than the Zune's eventual fate suggests.

Speaker: 00:01:22

The original Zune launched in the United States in November 2006, priced at about $250.

Speaker: 00:01:28

It came with a 30GB hard drive, a 3-inch screen, an FM tuner and wireless connectivity.

Speaker: 00:01:35

You could listen to music, watch videos, look at photos and personalise the screen.

Speaker: 00:01:41

Now nothing there sounds really special today, but the wireless feature was

Speaker: 00:01:44

where Microsoft wanted to make its mark.

Speaker: 00:01:46

Because with that feature you could send selected songs to another Zune without

Speaker: 00:01:50

plugging either player into a computer and that was something I found really cool.

Speaker: 00:01:55

Imagine sitting beside someone on a bus hearing a song you liked coming through

Speaker: 00:01:59

their headphones and being able to ask them to send it straight to your player.

Speaker: 00:02:03

No searching for the artist later, no writing down the title,

Speaker: 00:02:06

no waiting till you got home. Just pass the song over.

Speaker: 00:02:10

Now there was a catch. The recipient could only play a shared track up to three

Speaker: 00:02:14

times within three days. after which they'd need to buy it to keep listening.

Speaker: 00:02:18

You couldn't simply copy your entire music collection to everyone you met and

Speaker: 00:02:22

these restrictions were designed around music licensing and it kind of took

Speaker: 00:02:26

some of the shine off what was otherwise a pretty forward looking idea.

Speaker: 00:02:30

But the basic premise was a good one. Music was something you discovered through

Speaker: 00:02:33

other people so why shouldn't your music player help make that happen?

Speaker: 00:02:38

Microsoft even built a wider community around the concept, Zune Social.

Speaker: 00:02:42

Launched in 2007, Zune Social let people create profiles showing what they were

Speaker: 00:02:46

listening to, share recommendations, and explore other people's musical tastes.

Speaker: 00:02:52

There was a clear idea running through all of this. Music wasn't just a collection

Speaker: 00:02:56

of files sitting on your hard drive, it was a way to connect with people.

Speaker: 00:03:00

Now the Zune wasn't perfect, and this isn't an argument that it was secretly

Speaker: 00:03:04

the best music player ever made.

Speaker: 00:03:06

The iPod had a strong design, a familiar interface and the advantage of being

Speaker: 00:03:10

part of Apple's grown ecosystem.

Speaker: 00:03:13

Microsoft was asking people to choose a different device, use different software

Speaker: 00:03:17

and buy into another music service.

Speaker: 00:03:20

That was a lot to ask when the iPod was already so firmly established.

Speaker: 00:03:24

But the Zune had a personality of its own. The brown model became a running

Speaker: 00:03:28

joke, but it also made the device instantly recognisable.

Speaker: 00:03:33

The interface had its own look and feel, and the product was built around more

Speaker: 00:03:36

than just storing songs.

Speaker: 00:03:38

Microsoft was trying to give people a different relationship with their music.

Speaker: 00:03:42

And that distinction matters, because technology doesn't have to dominate a

Speaker: 00:03:45

market to mean something to the people who use it.

Speaker: 00:03:48

The Zune developed a loyal following, and some owners still talk about it with

Speaker: 00:03:53

a level of affection that might seem out of proportion to its place in the history books.

Speaker: 00:03:57

If you only measure a gadget by sales figures, that attachment can be hard to explain.

Speaker: 00:04:02

But if you've ever owned something that felt a little different from what everyone

Speaker: 00:04:05

else had, you'll probably understand it.

Speaker: 00:04:08

There's something personal about choosing the less obvious option.

Speaker: 00:04:12

Maybe you like the design. Maybe you prefer the software.

Speaker: 00:04:15

Maybe a friend gave you one, or you bought it at a point in your life when that

Speaker: 00:04:19

particular device became part of your daily routine.

Speaker: 00:04:22

Whatever the reason, it stopped being just a product, it became your product.

Speaker: 00:04:27

And that's one of the things that gets lost when we look back at technology

Speaker: 00:04:30

through a winner and loser lens.

Speaker: 00:04:32

While the iPod won the market, that doesn't mean every other music player was

Speaker: 00:04:36

worthless, or that everyone who chose something else made a mistake.

Speaker: 00:04:40

People don't build memories around market share. They remember the music they

Speaker: 00:04:44

listened to, the places they went, the friends they shared things with,

Speaker: 00:04:48

and the little objects that went along for the ride.

Speaker: 00:04:51

The Zune's a really good example because its ambitions were tied to sharing

Speaker: 00:04:54

and discovery It wanted music to move between people It wanted your listening

Speaker: 00:04:59

habits to become a way of finding new artists and connecting with other fans,

Speaker: 00:05:04

Now those ideas weren't exclusive to Microsoft and the Zune didn't invent social

Speaker: 00:05:08

music but they were central to what it was trying to be.

Speaker: 00:05:12

But then the world moved on. Microsoft stopped producing Zune hardware in 2011,

Speaker: 00:05:18

shifting its focus towards Windows Phone.

Speaker: 00:05:20

The Zune didn't become the future of portable music, and it never came close

Speaker: 00:05:24

to dislodging the iPod from its place in the market.

Speaker: 00:05:27

Still, the story doesn't end with the product disappearing from store shelves.

Speaker: 00:05:32

People kept their players, me included.

Speaker: 00:05:35

They kept talking about them, me included. the Zune became one of those pieces

Speaker: 00:05:39

of technology that outlived its commercial moment in a different way,

Speaker: 00:05:43

through the affection of the people who remember using it.

Speaker: 00:05:46

Maybe the Zune is remembered so fondly because it was an alternative.

Speaker: 00:05:50

It offered a different take on something millions of people already loved,

Speaker: 00:05:54

and it gave its owners a way to feel separate from the crowd.

Speaker: 00:05:57

It had limitations, and it lost the battle that mattered the most,

Speaker: 00:06:01

but a product's commercial fate isn't the same as its personal meaning.

Speaker: 00:06:05

The Zune didn't need to beat the iPod for someone to remember the album they

Speaker: 00:06:08

played on repeat, the songs they discovered through a friend,

Speaker: 00:06:11

or the years when that little brown player went everywhere with them.

Speaker: 00:06:15

And that's what makes a Zune an artefact. Not that it was misunderstood,

Speaker: 00:06:19

or that it should have won, but that its story is bigger than the outcome.

Speaker: 00:06:24

The device may have disappeared from everyday life, but the memories attached

Speaker: 00:06:28

to it didn't disappear with it.

Speaker: 00:06:31

I'm Danny Brown, and this is Artifacts.